Here are the cases to be made for players who should not be in the Hall of Fame, but are. This isn’t to say that they were stiffs or even below average, but just not Hall of Fame caliber.
We don’t argue for a grassroots movement to remove these men, but rather that the truly great Hall of Fame members deserve special recognition.
Listed in alphabetical order.
We solicit well-argued cases against membership. Nominees must be in the National Baseball Hall of Fame. No Frick or Spink award winners.